Audience Development

Food Fight Brings 850+ Opt-Ins in One Week!

St. Louis Magazine , circulation 40,000, hosted a Food Fight voting bracket featuring iconic foods from the city of St. Louis. The people of St. Louis — like those of other cities — have some passionate debates about the region’s most iconic foods. We expected a bracket of this type would drive tons of engagement from our readers.

The Idea

When we created the St. Louis Food Fight contest, we hoped that it would serve as an example of what St. Louis Magazine could do with future brackets while keeping potential revenue opportunities open as well.

We compiled a list of iconic St. Louis foods and narrowed them down, with a conscious effort to not use specific business or product names. In the future, similar brackets might include advertising opportunities as well. We decided to limit our bracket to eight entrants. This would give us three separate rounds of fan voting, each lasting four days. We kicked off the first round on a Thursday, with the final round ending on the following Friday.

Our focus was on generating the most engagement possible to get our audience excited. We leveraged social media, email, run-of-site ads, our online contest carousel, as well as our core media to get the word out.

The Big Success

Utilizing this fun topic to spark our audience’s passion was a hit! The bracket collected more than 1,750 votes and added more than 850 opt-ins across three magazine newsletters in one week. Plus, our email birthday club grew by nearly 280 people!

With this success, we now have proof of concept to provide to advertisers, and we can sell the series throughout the year. We’re hoping to launch many of these food-themed brackets in the future, starting with the St. Louis Food Fight Pizza Bracket. Read even more about the bracket here!


Jarrett will be speaking at Super Niche! Sign up now – down to the final tickets!



About Jarrett: Jarrett Medlin is editor-in-chief of St. Louis Magazine. Jarrett is dedicated to growing the magazine’s presence within the community of St. Louis, increasing engagement with their readers, and driving database growth and readership for all the magazine’s initiatives.


Niche Media has the best events, education, and training in media! Our super niched-out events & content give target-audience publishers in the B2C, hobbyist, B2B, city & regional, and association markets the tools they need to build revenue, audience, and more.